DISCUSS (129)

Women Are Better At Everything

Posted by majestic on June 29, 2011

First group of Women Marine Officer Candidates 1943Really?!? Meredith Melnick explains for TIME:

Recently in the Wall Street Journal, MarketWatch columnist David Weidner noted that women “do almost everything better” than men — from politics to corporate management to investing.

Weidner cites a new study by Barclays Wealth and Ledbury Research, which found that women were more likely than men to make money in the market, mostly because they didn’t take as many risks. And why are they risk-averse? Because they’re not as overconfident as men, the study found.

The study’s findings backed up those of previous research on the topic: in a 2001 study [PDF] of 35,000 American households with an account at a discount brokerage, financial scholars Brad Barber and Terrance Odean found that women’s risk-adjusted returns beat men’s by 1% annually. A 2005 study by Merrill Lynch found that 35% of women held an investment too long, compared with 47% of men. More recently, in 2009, a study by the mutual fund company Vanguard involving 2.7 million personal investors concluded that during the recent financial crisis, men were more likely than women to sell shares of stocks at all-time lows, leading to bigger losses among male traders. It also meant fewer gains when some of the stock values began to rise again.

What’s the problem with men? “There’s been a lot of academic research suggesting that men think they know what they’re doing, even when they really don’t know what they’re doing,” John Ameriks, the author of the Vanguard study, told the New York Times.

The reason for that overconfidence may come down to biology, research suggests…

[continues at TIME]

Related Posts with Thumbnails
  • Posted in: , , ,  
  • Will

    Feminism is just a foolish fad. When the economy tanks women will finally realize that everything that enabled them to rise to the top was made by men. And men will have to put it all back together. When disaster strikes, women scream for men…not other women…to save them and their children. Think about it.

  • http://twitter.com/gephsy SIMPLY GEPHSY3

    the point is we DONT NEED A MAN TO TAKE CARE OF US.. for what if we do it better

  • http://twitter.com/gephsy SIMPLY GEPHSY3

    I bet there was a woman behind a lot of those, because women weren’t taken seriously and/or viewed as inferior to men in the past

  • NotThatAnonymous

    I could be a progressive were it not for the constant misandry.

  • Anonymous

    Actually I think the idea that women were simply viewed as “inferior” is total bullshit. Women were viewed as different than men, more often than not. The fact that women usually did not have the same political and social roles as men in societies of the past is taken by many contemporary people to mean women were viewed as inferior.
    Edit: the thing with betting is that it means a lack of certainty due to a lack of evidence.

  • Bloodsexandviolence

    is it me or all the women stacked in this line up?

  • Joeyaburnette

    then why do you have to say it?

  • Anonymous

    Nobody said that everything for women is “hunky-dory”.  Way to throw the red-herring in there.  Nice.

  • Anonymous

    You’re wrong again.  It is not a non-issue. And your comment that  ALL white males have a privelage that women do not is clearly false.  Yes there are thoughs that do and inequality exists for sure.  But there are very little systemic discriminations that women face today in the West – as compared to income inequality amongst those who come from money and those that don’t.  .  Over stating this issue in the face of widespread income inequality (based on systemic corruption) and comparing a multimillionaire woman to a’  poverty-strickenred-neck’ and saying the only issue is that they “are rarely if ever competiing” makes you a ‘femanazi’.  Probably sucked into it by taking a feminist sociology course.

  • Anonymous

    What utter rubbish.  I am not sexist, racist and I don’t hate women or minorities, nor am I in any way at all complicit in structures that discriminate against these groups.

    First year Sociology major?

  • Anonymous

    Your point would be what exactly?  Hamas is the democratically elected government of the Palestinians.  And they are a resistance movement fighting against the internationally recognized illegal occupation of their homeland by American, European and ME Zionist Jews.  I should add that it’s well established that Zionism is a fascist, racist system whereby only Jewish people have full democratic rights…

  • Anonymous

    Sorry. That was supposed to be a reply to a comment about Code Pink and Hamas….

  • Anonymous

    From what I’ve read, TG is miles more ‘progressive’ than you…

  • Tuna Ghost

    It’s hyperbole, not a red herring.  The distinction is important.

  • http://pulse.yahoo.com/_ZOIMLIPRB2LC2AL5SOURAL4DJ4 Womiktorn Smith

    Yes, there is no harm is saying so because woman have been giving their best at any stage.And definitely.. they deserve for this complement.

    http://www.buzzflash.net/story.php?id=1655679

  • Leetahlee

    I take issue with the whole “battle of the sexes” notion, and the “one-upping” that the well-noted quotation (by a man) chosen by the author (a woman) has prompted.  Seriously.  And with the name-calling and generalizations based on sex, or gender. 

    As an egalitarian, I recognize that a lot of the well-intended “fixes” for inequality toward women sometimes engenders resentment on the part of men, and I try to advocate for solutions that don’t tip the scales from one side to the other.  But fighting back by suggesting that women aren’t being discriminated against anymore, or never were in the first place demonstrates at least a serious gap in knowledge about the issues and even basic history.  There’s plenty of evidence just from the past century in the US alone that indicates women were viewed as inferior and not taken seriously, without even counting other countries/cultures:

    http://law.jrank.org/pages/10192/Sex-Discrimination-Historical-Background.html

    In response to another poster who suggested that legally women are advantaged over men, I’m sure you probably could point to a few advantages.  That goes back to the “fixes” I mentioned earlier.  On the whole, however, women still have to fight a lot harder just to get the same rights as men in the workplace such as salary, benefits, advancement, and representation in leadership (i.e., executive boards).  Women face  insidious things like harassment, a lack of women mentors and being taken less seriously.  Socially, they are targeted for violence, have greater rates of poverty and are routinely exploited as sex objects in virtually all forms of media. 

    Changing discriminatory practices is not simply a matter of signing a bill into law.  It’s also a matter of executing that law fairly and consistently, and changing a society that makes assumptions about men and women based on stereotypes.  I don’t think most women expect to have everything work to their advantage in all things, or even to have everything be exactly equal in every area of life (we’re not in heaven yet). 

    But just because some issues have been addressed, or just because the problem is such a huge one doesn’t give a person carte blanche to dismiss the issue as resolved, or conversely, unresolvable.  Discrimination is glaringly obvious when you see how low a percentage of women hold positions of leadership compared to how many of them are working in the same company at lower levels, across multiple industries.  It’s obvious when 1.5 MILLION women try to bring Wal-Mart to court for discriminatory practices, and Bayer employees do the same.  It’s obvious when you see several people’s salaries while working on a spreadsheet project at work, and every single man is paid TWICE what the women are, while all hold the same title and boast equivalent experience and education. 

    On the contrary, it’s precisely these blatant injustices that should have the many wonderful men out there with their wives, daughters, sisters, etc. protesting and petitioning for change.  The EEOC can only handle so many cases.  They’re underfunded and understaffed.  This puts the burden on the person or group that has experienced the discrimination to put their own neck(s) out.  And that’s a big part of why the discrimination continues: there’s little support to be had when trying to fight for what you deserve.  That’s why women are so vehement about this: they want their men’s support.  Maybe not all of them go about it the best way.  But why throw out the baby with the bathwater?

  • Anonymous

    You could have made your point in and included many of your justifications with 1/4 the words used. As to the inequality thing; I was exaggerating, just like I see people exaggerate how horrible men are and how ’simple’, black and white, the issue of “inequality” of the sexes is.
    Anyway, sometimes I wish women would takeover the more traditional roles of men so I can stay at home and take care of kids, cook, clean, etc. The best deal back-in-the-day and STILL is to be born a little pretty rich girl. They are so oppressed! Little Princess. For women beauty is power, unless they’re super stupid and/or emotionally crippled. If on a scale of 1 -10 a chick is a even an 8 but surely a 9 or 10… cha-ching. Rich Man money is your entitlement.

  • Anonymous

    You could have made your point in and included many of your justifications with 1/4 the words used. As to the inequality thing; I was exaggerating, just like I see people exaggerate how horrible men are and how ’simple’, black and white, the issue of “inequality” of the sexes is.
    Anyway, sometimes I wish women would takeover the more traditional roles of men so I can stay at home and take care of kids, cook, clean, etc. The best deal back-in-the-day and STILL is to be born a little pretty rich girl. They are so oppressed! Little Princess. For women beauty is power, unless they’re super stupid and/or emotionally crippled. If on a scale of 1 -10 a chick is a even an 8 but surely a 9 or 10… cha-ching. Rich Man money is your entitlement.

  • Old Soul

    A better one? 

  • Reddendouble

    how can anyone say they r held down and not treated fair…have u ever had the cops call for domestic disturbance??? who goes to jail????  have you ever had a child???who automatically gets custody????and even if u get joint custody 5050 who still has to pay child support????have you ever applied for any kind of assistance from the government???? i can tell u who automatically gets approved. food stamps….section 8…..wic….babysitter vouchers….grants…..no questions asked…..there r sooooo many laws and practices designed to help and protect women and still u complain….this will sound funny but be a white male in need of assistance and see what it gets u…..quit bitchin bitches

  • http://www.facebook.com/amber.lipczynski Amber Lipczynski

    Yeah, some can actually… myself, for instance… I’d gladly prove it too but I’d rather not to put a video of myself on the internets for fear of my family seeing it… just requires a little bit of, um, manual interference, pulling back the lips and whatnot… I’ll let you use your imagination there. ;-)

  • http://www.facebook.com/amber.lipczynski Amber Lipczynski

    I’m sure I could do that too, if only I knew braille. LMAO

  • Surrealias

    On a personal note… I know [i]plenty[/i] of women who are much harder workers (and much more willing to do the work without whining about it) than most of the men I know.

  • Anonymous
  • Patchi

    That last sentence was clear, concise, and best of all: very true!
    Male

  • Patchi

    He didn’t say it was a conspiracy by all men. Any thinking human has to admit that for thousands of years women have been generally relegated to serving men. Recently, this has been changing. And this is a good thing! No human is of lesser value than you. Listen to those who feel oppressed… there might be a legitimate claim in there.

  • DoctorG

    I’m a behavioral neuroscientist, and can tell you that this is, as we say in sciencey circles, a load of poo.  If you look at the source literature, the authors of said studies are overwhelmingly female, and very often in women’s studies programs at their respective institutions.  Along with the bogus “1 in 4″ rape statistic, it’s fodder for media outlets and women’s study sections.  Real scientists don’t even pause over much of the published materials in journals endemic to these studies.

  • Biggus23x

    “the authors of said studies are overwhelmingly female”

    So, on this logic, any study which shows men to be superior at anything can be safely ignored if the authors are male?

    “Along with the bogus “1 in 4″ rape statistic”

    You’re claiming this is false? What is the true figure and how do you know, please?

    “Real scientists don’t even pause over much of the published materials in journals endemic to these studies.”

    Really? On what basis do you dismiss this research?

  • Betty Greenway

    Of course women are better at everything. From multi tasking to caring for other, plus we look better in heels!