Holocaust: noun. Widespread destruction, especially by fire; a massive slaughter; a sacrificial offering consumed entirely by flames.On April 11th, 2000, British High Court Justice Charles Gray ruled Penguin Books and Emory University professor Deborah Lipstadt did not libel David Irving. Irving filed suit after she described him as a Holocaust denier in her book, 'Denying The Holocaust: The Growing Assault On Truth And Memory' (1993).
In retrospect, the verdict seemed obvious. Historical events deserve to be examined with the official version challenged. The attack on Irving has been disturbing, even if his conclusions are wrong: he's been banned from five countries for his opinions, and was dropped by publisher 'St. Martin's Press' over the controversy. Suing for libel to strike back at critics is hardly a free speech defence, especially when the charges made by Ms. Lipstadt - that Irving is a historian with a scary political ideology who distorts evidence to fit his agenda - are accurate. Whatever your view about Irving's motives or politics, one thing is clear: considering how outmanned he was in court during his frivolous lawsuit - he represented himself, while Lipstadt and Penguin were defended by well-paid attorneys - his fight appears more pathetic than a menacing threat to free speech.
It is useful to compare how Irving's dubious claims met with universal scorn by mainstream media, while a recent officially sanctioned attempt to deny a more recent holocaust in Waco is repeated without criticism. The term 'holocaust' is a loaded one, yet by any definition of the term by Webster, what happened at Waco applies.
Honest examination of a 'Forward Looking Infra-red' (FLIR) videotape, taken over the infamous April 19th, 1993 siege, makes clear even to untrained eyes that US Federal agents fired on the Branch Davidian compound. Expert opinions back up the observation. Dr. Edward Allard, considered the world authority on infra-red imaging systems, noted numerous flashes which he insisted were gunshots fired into the compound. His terse conclusion: "This type of behavior, men running up and down the building, firing automatic weapons into a church is disgusting."
Carlos Ghigliotti, a thermal imaging analyst hired by the 'House Government Reform Committee' to review the evidence, stated plainly: "The gunfire from the ground is there, without a doubt."
Except from 'Vector Data Systems', a British consulting firm hired by the 'Justice Department' to analyze the video. In a report (May 10th, 2000), VDS claim that flashes of light were not FBI gunfire, instead caused by sunlight glinting off metal and debris. Coincidentally, VDS is a defense contractor with ties to the Pentagon, NSA, IRS, FBI and the BATF. The claims are repeated by another defense contractor, 'Maryland Advanced Development Laboratory' (MADLAB). It also curiously echoes Nazi Holocaust deniers' pseudo-scientific claims that mass-murder in concentration camps didn't happen.
Waco denials would fail to convince FLIR film viewers who has them fresh in mind. Fortunately for the deniers, that is a definite minority of the populace, and of those writing for media outlets (who repeated the report without criticism, always falsely referring to VDS as 'independent'). What has received less coverage is the sudden bad luck of truly independent Waco investigators. Ghigliotti was found dead in his office (April 28th, 2000), before he could report his final results. Dr. Allard suffered a stroke the Thursday before the latest FLIR test, so he was unable to contribute to the analysis.
Some look at the recent bad fortune of Ghigliotti and Dr. Allard and suggest it is not all a coincidence. Such suspicions are mocked as crazed "conspiracy theories." Maybe so. Maybe the whole episode proves that the establishment has no qualms denying holocausts when it is convenient.
"Never forget" is a common plea of those dedicated to memorializing the victims of Nazi atrocities. Obviously, we already have.